Skip to Content

Secret Ballot Watch

Reasons EFCA Must Fail No. 5: (Post)card Check Is No Better Than Card Check

| Posted in Secret Ballot Watch

The card check is in the mail – and it’s just as good as voting for a union by secret ballot. If you believe that, there’s a bridge in Brooklyn, N.Y., you might be interested in purchasing. With public opposition to the anti-worker card check plan mounting, its supporters have concocted a series of alternative proposals. Unfortunately for workers, the alternatives are as bad as the original. One i... Read more »

Reasons EFCA Must Fail No. 6: Card Check Does Not Have A Friend In Pennsylvania – Or Anywhere Else

| Posted in Secret Ballot Watch

Supporters of the Employee Free Choice Act must be a lonely bunch. Poll after poll shows their numbers are few as Americans have soundly rejected the act, and no wonder: It sets aside the secret ballot in favor of a public majority sign-up. It offers forced government contracts and could make America less competitive in the global economy – all during a lengthy recession. How strongly are people a... Read more »

Reasons EFCA Must Fail No. 7: Three Words: Forced … Government … Contracts

| Posted in Secret Ballot Watch

Since it was first conceived, the so-called Employee Free Choice Act has received much attention about its ability to set aside a worker’s right to a secret ballot. Indeed, this very series was created, in part, to highlight why the secret ballot needs protection. But there are other dangers lurking in this legislation. Another part of EFCA equally troubling to workers, scholars, and activists is ... Read more »

Reasons EFCA Must Fail No. 8: Those Clever Canadians Could Outpace Us In the Global Marketplace

| Posted in Secret Ballot Watch

If you want to see what America’s economic future would be like under the Employee Free Choice Act, look to the north. Canada has experimented with similar laws about the public sign-up card check process for forming unions, and that experience has not been good. Card check and the forced arbitration that goes with it have wreaked havoc on our northern neighbor’s economy. In fact, Canada’s card ch... Read more »

Reasons EFCA Must Fail No. 9: Have You SEEN the Unemployment Rate Lately?

| Posted in Secret Ballot Watch

Ever hear the phrase, “making a bad situation worse”? That’s exactly what would happen to our economy – which, unfortunately, is in a “bad situation” at the moment – if some in Congress and their special interest allies get their way with enactment of the so-called Employee Free Choice Act. A report issued in March found the act would destroy jobs and stifle productivity at a time when our economy... Read more »

Reasons EFCA Must Fail No. 10: Even George McGovern is Against It

| Posted in Secret Ballot Watch

One would think George McGovern would be a shoo-in as a supporter of the Employee Free Choice Act. In his acceptance speech for the 1972 Democratic presidential nomination, he called for “justice and jobs for all our people” – a vision that supporters of EFCA claim pursuit of today. So it was quite a surprise – especially to the act’s supporters – when the former South Dakota senator came out agai... Read more »

(At Least) 10 Reasons EFCA Must Fail

| Posted in Secret Ballot Watch

With a bill as bad as the Employee Free Choice Act, limiting the list of flaws to a top 10 can be quite a challenge. Still, with apologies to David Letterman, below are the first (but certainly not the last) 10 reasons why the anti-worker card check scheme must fail: 10. Even George McGovern is against it. 9. Have you SEEN the unemployment rate lately? 8. Those clever Canadians could outpace us in... Read more »

“Free Choice” And Mistrust

| Posted in Secret Ballot Watch

A company can’t compete in today’s economy if workers and managers can’t trust each other – and the Employee Free Choice Act will breed that mistrust in the workplace. That’s what Kevin D. Manship says in a letter to The News Herald of Morganton, N.C. Manship is a facility manager of the local branch of Caterpillar Inc., a Fortune 500 company which makes construction and mining equipment, diesel a... Read more »

Card Check and the Classroom

| Posted in Secret Ballot Watch

There’s a lesson to be learned about the Employee Free Choice Act – and it’s not just about what this special interest ploy can do to a weakened economy. The act can stifle education reform as well. Take it from former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney. He vetoed a similar proposal in his state a few years ago, but his successor signed it into law. At the time, most saw the new law in economic terms ... Read more »

How “Free Choice” Can Make Free Speech Costly

| Posted in Secret Ballot Watch

The closer you look at the Employee Free Choice Act, the worse it becomes. Of course, there is the act’s ability to set aside workers’ right to a secret ballot and expose them to intimidation. There is also the act’s ability to impose forced government contracts and kill jobs in a weakened economy. But John S. Irving, a former general counsel to the National Labor Relations Board, has found yet an... Read more »

Stay Connected